Tuesday, November 1, 2011

What will it take?

These days, there is little good news and lots of bad.  Almost every day brings reports of dishonesty, inhumanity, incompetence, or indifference so inconsistent with our image of ourselves and our country that it makes the blood boil. There is so much bad news that the rage it generates is dissipated by its pervasiveness. It’s hard to choose which of the many  horrible conditions and events we hear about is worst and equally difficult to decide which of many possible causative events is the most likely underlying cause of our many problems.  We know things have gone seriously wrong, but we’re just not sure what we should or can do about it. So most of us, uncertain about the facts and unsure of how to proceed, wait and hope for clarity. 

It makes one wonder what it will take to move us to action.  

Every now and then, someone breaks through with a summary which makes clear just how bad things are.  Last weekend, Charles Blow reported on a recent study by the Bertelsmann Stiftung Foundation in Germany. The Foundation has done a comparison of social conditions in the 34 countries that belong to the OECD – The Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development.  20 years ago, I would have expected the United States to be the leader in most categories.  Since we have clearly abandoned policies that will produce leadership in a host of areas – education, health care, economic equality, and our physical infrastructure among others – I no longer cling to the illusion that we are leaders --- but I was not prepared for a scorecard as bad as what turned up. 

The study ranks the 34 OECD member countries in nine areas: Social Justice, Poverty Prevention, Overall Poverty Rate, Child Poverty Rate, Senior Citizen Poverty Rate, Income Inequality, Pre-Primary Education and Health.  In five of the nine areas, the United States ranks among the bottom five countries – which means there are at least 29 that do better! In two areas – Senior Citizen Poverty and Pre-Primary Education – we rank in the bottom 10, which means there are at least 24 that do better.  And in Health, we rank in the bottom 15, which means there at least 19 – and probably more, since we don’t know our exact rank – that do better.

It’s a very troubling scorecard, which unhappily corroborates  similar results produced by other studies. We’ve heard before that despite spending far more per citizen than other countries, our health care results are worse than those of countries that spend lots less.  We also know that our educational system is failing our kids, and that our academic results are falling further and further behind those of countries with more rigorous, if less expensive, educational systems. And the National Academy of Science has told us very clearly that our infrastructure is no longer competitive and that we are more than $2 trillion in arrears on maintenance spending alone – much less what we should have been spending on new facilities. 
Things have reached the point where about the only area in which we lead is defense spending, which is not buying the assets needed to produce the kinds of society we want to leave our kids and grandkids.  Excessive defense spending also begs the question of whether the values we are supposedly protecting from others are being eroded away by our political system here at home. 

It is increasingly difficult to find any course of action on which a majority of Americans agree.  We do seem to agree that our political system has failed – barely 10% think well of Congress and less than a majority think the President is doing a good job. The” all for one and one for all” spirit of years past has vanished and we seem moribund, unable to agree on either what the problem is or how to fix it.
Whatever else we do, we must find a way to come together again.  We need a political structure that will produce a government we can trust and a plan to restore America that we can agree on.  That’s a tall order and one that seem increasingly out of reach of our bickering politicians. 

But as a wise man once said, the longest journey begins with a single step.  In my view, a big part of our problem can be attributed to the fact that we have less common interests than we had in times past, that too many of us see the other guy as too different from ourselves to be reasoned with, and likely part of a social strata that is either beneath us or one to which we can no longer aspire.  A big part of the America I grew up in was the almost universal belief that anyone could do anything if they really wanted to – and since many of us badly wanted to improve ourselves, the system produced lots of social and geographic mobility. 

One of the things that has cost us our common interest is the steadily increasing inequality of wealth and income in America. In today’s America, the top 1% takes 17% of all income, while the bottom half of the population gets only 13% -- the worst disparity since 1929.  Unless things change soon, the country will suffer from even worse inequality 10 years hence.  Increasing inequality has serious social and economic implications to which our increasingly ideological mind sets have paid far too little attention. If you are interested knowing more about those consequences, and how they are contributing to our many difficulties, you might want to spend 15 minutes listening to Richard Wilkinson go through some very impressive data laying out how income inequality has impacted societies around the world. You can find his talk at http://www.ted.com/talks/richard_wilkinson.html 

My own view is that in one way or another – there are various alternatives available – we must reduce both income and wealth inequality, and re-ignite the spirit of the common good.  Doing so will not be easy. 

We are in the midst of a political campaign – they seem  to have become perpetual – during which we should be having substantive discussions of why things are as they are. Unhappily, our prospective leaders assiduously avoid all serious subjects and seem focused on nothing beyond attacking one another about various and sundry trivia.  Even more troubling is the emergence of political action groups of every stripe, handsomely funded by special interests whose financial contributions are no longer limited by law. Unless I miss my guess, this year’s campaign will be the most expensive ever, and it will be even more difficult than it has been in the past for citizens to gather substantive information or for candidates to speak truth. 

This problem isn’t going to be fixed unless we – the citizens of the great United States of America – fix it.  Each of us needs to set aside our ideological pre-convictions, gather information from many sources (including those ideologically inconsistent with our own views),  think carefully, discuss and debate more openly than we have in the past, formulate possible solutions – and insist that those who seek to lead deal with the substance of the country’s problems.  There is no other way back to greatness.  


  1. It's a good start, by recognizing the problem. There are lots of e-mails circulating for a 28th ammendment. The movement to "Occupy wall Street" will hopefully coalesce into the changes we need."www.getmoneyout.com" is a movement to remove money from politics. President Eisenhower said it years ago-beware of the military industrial complex. We are now there!!

  2. I want to compliment you on a piece that so succinctly and correctly describes the challenges we face as a nation. We spend more than any other nation on a per-capita basis on education, yet our math and science scores rank near the bottom of the OECD. We spend more than any other nation on a per-capita basis on healthcare, yet we have tens of millions of people uninsured and are at or near the bottom of the OECD when it comes to key measures of health. It amazes me that more people aren't concerned with these issues.

    And as you note, income inequality has been rising and shows no sign of slowing down anytime soon. When I look at countries that have suffered from high levels of income inequality for long periods of time, and I extrapolate from their experience to what could happen here, I'm frightened at an existential level -- I'm frightened that we could face a future where our children and grandchildren live in a country that looks radically different from ours, and not in a good way.

  3. This article is dead right on target..e-mails to our congressional representatives are replied with their political positioning instead of possible solutions...how do we seek out and identify those leaders who have the power and influence to set a new direction for the new generations and maintain a capitalist society while necessarily redistributing the wealth with extensive socialism? I was heartened by an article in this mornings L.A. Times about the wealthy Robert King and his wife who donated $150 million to Stanford University to developing an Institute for Innovation in Developing Economies...his principles need application in the U.S....the sme is true of philanthropists like Bill Gates & Warren Buffett who strive to get their wealth directly to the needy, circumventing a bureaucratic U.S. government...as Lee Iaccoca said "Where have All The Leaders Gone?"

    A friend of Ted Tedesco's,
    Bill Knauer

  4. I meant WITHOUT extensive socialism!!!

    Bill Knauer

  5. The problem is that the political arena has become infested by those attracted who are willing to manipulate it for their own purposes and know full well there's no chance of consequences.

    Has anyone ever seen a poor politician in recent times? Why would anyone of sound mind refer to any politician as "The Honorable"?

    Thomas Jefferson said it best while writing our country's Declaration of Independence:

    "But when a long train of abuses and usurpations, pursuing invariably the same Object evinces a design to reduce them under absolute Despotism, it is their right, it is their duty, to throw off such Government, and to provide new Guards for their future security."

    Jefferson, as these words came from the Declaration, was speaking of the British King but I see little difference between that situation and the actions of the present Washington DC elite.

    Frank Szabo

  6. As usual, right on Mr. Crandall!

  7. Bob, you've once again hit the nail on the head. Your diagnosis is spot on. But we all grasp for the therapy -- what we need to do to get the republic moving in the right direction again.

    In the past few years I have moved from optimist to pessimist on natisonal affairs. But that ain't helping. As you often and memorably wrote in your AA margin notes, "Aaaaaaarghhh"!

  8. Well-said Mr. Crandall. And while I'm here, may I make a desperate plea for your return
    to AA?

  9. Replies
    1. Wayne I still am not sure that this is Robert Crandall who writes this blog? Although the thoughts are well written it just doesn't strike me as something that Crandall would get involved with? Aside from the fact that not too many people are following this in the first place. If it really was Crandall he would make a video as proof? Oh and fix your station, it's a mess! Replace the broken equiptment. The tractors are horrendous and unsafe and you know this. And some of your new CSM's are just plain Nazis.

  10. Would you mind saying a few words about the AMR Chapter 11 filing? As a 30 year frequent flyer on American, what I appreciated most about your era was the honesty in your letters to the customer.

    While I’m saddened by AA’s decline, I’m not terribly exercised by the bankruptcy. After all “everyone does it these days.”

    But one thing that sticks out like a sore thumb is there’s no email in my inbox this morning from Arpey or Horton or whomever telling me not to worry: my miles, my flights, and especially all the extra benefits and services I’ve come to expect from AAdvantage Gold & Platinum will all continue as if nothing happened.

    I simply cannot believe no one thought of doing this, and if they did, why they didn’t make sure it got into the customers’ inboxes the moment the story went out this morning.



  11. There are many cultural issues here, but one I think that has caused this divisiveness is the apparent disconnect between work and reward nowadays. There are plenty of rich who simply don’t deserve their fortune and plenty of poor who are living beyond their means without consequence. Everybody sees evil in the other and are being pushed to a side. We need to fix this link and quit talking about the rare anecdotal failures of our society.

  12. It's been a very long time now since your last post. Do you have any more thoughts to share with us?

  13. Post more! You have great ideas!